Sunday, October 4, 2009
Post 9/28 - 10/4
During the discussions and lectures about World War I, there was one thing I couldn't stop thinking was "How could the Germans be so stupid?" From the beginning it seems like they were destined to lose the war, mostly due to their inability to plan correctly. The Schlieffen Plan in particular is kind of stunning in how shortsighted it was, requiring a speedy defeat of the French and a lack of participation by the British. That said, I do feel like the overconfidence has a very logical explanation, the Germans increase in industrial and economic power made them feel like they were above the rest of Europe. It seems that military and industrial technology had grown faster than anyone expected, and they were left to fight a war using what was then high-tech equipment, but without a strategy that could take advantage of these advances. Then, you've got the German navy, which was probably an even bigger failure than the Schileffen plan due to its inability to do much of anything. While I'd already known that there was still a Prussian influence in Germany during this time, due to the lands that had been Prussia making up the majority of the Germanic Empire, Germany's failures in WW1 seem to be directly due to this influence. Still, I'm left wondering how anyone involved thought this could be a good idea, unless they were so blinded by Germanic pride that they couldn't imagine anything less than a total victory.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
you know I kinda had the same question running through my mind. for this supposedly ridiculous powerful military, they seemed to have an awful lot of loop holes in their grand scheme. I know that there are risks that you have to take in war, but their whole strategy was banking on chance and hope. Why on earth would you risk that?! I feel that you brought up a good point: Germanic Pride. They were so dazzled by the idea of their army being so great and the rising greatness of their Navy that they failed to see the reality of the matter. No matter how great your army is, bad strategy will always see your ruin
ReplyDeleteCertainly when viewed from hindsight, German war plans seem so ridiculous but let us not forget that Germany almost succeeded (in conquering Paris at least.) For many, the situation in Germany was intolerable and war seemed to be the only solution. Many also felt that war was inevitable and that it was better to fight sooner rather than later.
ReplyDelete